Dawn Hughes to the stand. "She had learned from a very early age how to care take, how to live in a situation that is mired in chaos, how to take care of a parent that is passed out, nodded out from heroin," Hughes said. 35 "a- knocking on the door. All calls are toll-free and confidential. Cookies collect information about your preferences and your device and are used to make the site work as you expect it to, to understand how you interact with the site, and to show advertisements that are targeted to your interests. Copyright 2023 PopCulture.com. Dawn Hughes, who testified before jurors on Tuesday. Heard's attorney asked Hughes how she had corroborated the reported incidents, and Hughes offered the example during a 2014 incident when Depp allegedly kicked Heard in the back after accusing her of having an affair with actor James Franco. Dr. Hughes also stated she disagrees with the findings of Dr. Shannon Curry, the psychologist called to the stand by Depp's legal team. "You're stuck in this vicious cycle of how can I be with this man who hurts me yet I love him so much," Hughes testified. On Tuesday, Hughes said Heard reported several acts of physical violence from Depp, including him pushing her, shoving her, slapping her, choking her, and kicking her. Dr Shannon Curry, a psychologist called by Mr Depp's legal team, was seen sitting in the front row among other attendees as Dr Dawn Hughes, called by Ms Heard's team, disagreed with her testimony. Save 20% On Olaplex Haircare Bestsellers to Repair Damaged Strands, Save $105 on This Highly-Rated Dyson Vacuum Alternative from Amazon, Hailey Bieber's Favorite Denim Shorts Are On Sale Now at Amazon, Khloe Kardashian's Good American Drops New Neon Swimwear Collection, Judge Denies Amber Heard's Motion to Dismiss Johnny Depp Defamation Lawsuit. Heard had claimed to the psychologist about a few accusations. Curry who was hired by Johnny Depp's legal team to assess Heard and was present in the courtroom during Hughes' Tuesday testimony reviewed Heard's case files and met with her twice, 12 hours total. "There are indications, as I've mentioned before, of the sexual assault and the sexual abuse, and how he would, when he was angry and when he was drunk it was mostly drug- and alcohol-fueled rage when he would throw her on the bed and try to have sex with her," Dr. Hughes said. Dr. Forensic Psychologist Dr Dawn Hughes, PhD testified on Amber's behalf during Amber Heard and Johnny Depp's "You defamed me." "No, you defamed me." trial. Updated on: May 4, 2022 / 7:14 AM "I diagnosed Ms. Heard with post traumatic stress disorder," Dr. Hughes said. Amber Heard at the 2016 Met Gala on the left and Elon Musk at the 2022 Met Gala on the right. Even though Depp wasn't named in the op-ed, he testified that the implication that he abused Heard, which he denies doing, hurt his career. Depp has said he never physically attacked Heard, and that she was the aggressor who routinely hit him and threw things at him through the course of their relationship. Depp's lawyers focused on the evidence Hughes considered and ignored when forming her opinion.Subscribe to LiveNOW from FOX! "Anger is a very normal emotion to having been abused," she said. Johnny Depp's spokesperson issues heartbreaking statement about the last few days of trial. Depp is suing Heard for $50 million in Fairfax County Circuit Court after Heard wrote a December2018 op-ed piece in The Washington Postdescribing herself as "a public figure representing domestic abuse." Hughes said her evaluation found that there was a "high degree of serious violence" perpetrated by Depp toward Heard, while Heard perpetrated "mild" violence toward Depp. Hughes said Depp on one occasion manually penetrated Heard in anger after witnessing Heard's interactions with a woman. Heard blinked back tears, and her lips and chin quivered at times as Hughes described the abuse. Watch a non-stop stream of breaking news, live events and stories across the nation. Amber Heard started dating Elon Musk after seeing him at the 2016 Met Ball just weeks after her breakup with husband Johnny Depp but her heart wasn't in the relationship, a psychologist testified in court on Wednesday. Hughes said she based her testimony on 29 hours of interviews with Heard, as well as interviews with her therapists and a review of court documents. The psychologist also pointed out that Curry's assessment that Heard scored in the 98th percentile of intentional exaggeration went against that test's instructions, which point out that percentile scores should not be used, because the test is used on people who have trauma and is therefore not a normal percentile curve. But Hughes said there's a difference in the violence when a smaller person strikes at a larger person, and that Depp's violence was intimidating and threatened her safety, but Heard's violence did not have the same effect on Depp. "Mutual abuse isn't really a term of art that we use," Hughes said. Although she did not name Depp in the piece, she wrote about being a domestic violence survivor. "She truly, truly believed she could fix Mr. Depp and rid him of his substance abuse problems, but that did not work," Hughes added. It is not uncommon for a victim to yell at her partner or become violent and fight back, according to the expert. LIVE COVERAGE: Johnny Depp v Amber Heard Defamation Trial Happening in court:Day 14Cross Examination of Dr. Dawn Hughes, a forensic psychologist, on Heard's team called. Dr. Heard told Hughes that her "soul was broken" when she started dating Elon Musk in May 2016. Stay up to date with what you want to know. People who are observing them will feel like it's almost play-acting She never really indicated a vulnerable feeling of her own. The actor's talent manager, Jack Whigham, testified via video link that Depp had a $22.5 million deal with Disney to star in a sixth Pirates of the Caribbean film. Dawn Hughes, a forensic psychologist who evaluated Heard for the lawsuit and determined that she had been the victim of intimate partner violence committed by Depp. Depp's team has claimed his career was "destroyed" after Heard's 2018 Washington Post op-ed was published. "She learned she could love someone who hurts her, she knew that people who hurt her also can love her," Hughes said of Heard. Johnny Depp V. Amber Heard: Actress' Motion to Dismiss Lawsuit Denied, Johnny Depp vs Amber Heard Defamation Trial: Watch Live on ET, Johnny Depp's Bodyguard Alleges Amber Heard Abused the Actor, By signing up, you agree to our The court upheld the outlet's claims as being "substantially true" and Heard testified to back up the claims. All rights reserved. Four tests backed up the diagnosis, Hughes said. Hughes' testimony could counter testimony from psychologist Dr. Shannon Curry, who was called to the stand by Depp's team on April 26. One of the notes addressed relationships she had with other men, including billionaire Tesla CEO Elon Musk. Moments of dominance, moments of him trying to get control over her.". US actor Johnny Depp listens in the courtroom at the Fairfax County Circuit Court in Fairfax, Virginia, on May 2, 2022. "There were three statements that we evaluated to see how they affected her emotionally and psychologically and it was my determination theydid.". Amber Heard's first witness was Dr. ", She continued, "That was what was pushing the symptoms, that was what was related to the intrusive phenomena, that was related to her avoidance, that was related to her differences inher mood, that was related to her avoidance efforts, so the cause was the intimate partner violence by Mr. Depp is suing Heard, his ex-wife, for defamation for a Washington Post op-ed she wrote in 2018, in which she said she is the victim of domestic violence. The psychologist, Dawn Hughes, testified she conducted a 29-hour evaluation with Heard. Dr. Hughes'diagnosis comes after a forensic psychological evaluation, held over the course of 29 hours, in which she conducted a clinical interview with Heard and asked her about her life both before and after her marriage to Depp. Limited commentary. Stay up to date with what you want to know. Depp.". In his trial, which began in April in Fairfax County, Virginia, he testified that Heard was quick to anger and frequently assaulted him. The Pirates of the Caribbean actor originally filed the $50 million lawsuit in March 2019. Hughes said Depp called almost every male and female actor Heard worked with and said he had eyes on set. The nonsense coming from Amber Heard's 'expert witness' Dr Dawn Hughes makes it very clear that we are living in a ridiculous farce of a world, and there are some serious sex bias problems and skew within the psychology profession. And she testified, in her opinion as an expert witness in the case, that "mutual abuse" was an oversimplified concept in relationships. Dr. All Rights Reserved. Heard was expected to be her defense's first witness, but her lawyers chose a different way to begin. During the defamation trial on Tuesday, Amber Heard's legal team called Dr. Unidad Editorial Informacin Deportiva, S.L.U. Hughes testified it was clear that Heard suffered from "intimate partner violence" characterized by coercive control, surveillance, and other factors. Copyright 2023 CBS Interactive Inc. All rights reserved. Dr. "I was heartbroken. Tune in to the Law\u0026Crime Network for daily coverage of this high-profile trial. He claimed Heard allegedly threw a Red Bull can at Depp in March 2015 during an argument at their Los Angeles home. But his obsessiveness would mean the fight "would always come back," Hughes continued. Dawn Hughes . Amber Heard had PTSD because of "intimate partner violence" from Johnny Depp, according to a forensic psychologist. Dr Hughes is president-elect of the trauma division of the American. The tests Curry used were misapplied, she said, and Hughes used three tests that she testified had the expected scores for someone who had PTSD. Topics: Amber. Hughes also said that during a trip to Australia, Depp penetrated Heard with a bottle. A week ago, forensic psychologist Dr. Shannon Curry testified the opposite, saying that Heard showed no signs of PTSD, instead diagnosing her with borderline and histrionic personality disorders. Both Depp and Amber Heard have continually testified in the defamation case. As part of her assessment of Heard, Hughes asked about Heard's other relationships with men. The statement read "Over the last 3 1/2 weeks, we've seen and heard from nearly 30 witnesses who have attested to and supported Mr. Depp's claims that Ms. Heard defamed him in her 2018 op-ed," according to the statement. Dawn Hughes, a forensic psychologist, reviewed records related to Heard's mental health, had her complete lengthy questionnaires, and interviewed her over several appointments in person and. Hughes said Depp didn't want Heard to show nudity on camera, didn't want her to act with certain actors because of "his obsessive jealousy," and he criticized her ambition. All rights reserved. Hughes disagreed with Curry's assessment, saying that Heard had a "normal" clinical profile, with no scores elevated enough to warrant a personality disorder diagnosis. Hughes who said she "always" goes into an evaluation with a "healthy dose of skepticism" diagnosed Heard with PTSD, which has to have a cause. Depp.". The lawsuit was filedin Fairfax County, Virginia, where The Washington Post's online servers are located. About not identifying PTSD, Curry said, "Just because somebody doesn't have PTSD doesn't mean that they weren't harmed psychologically by whatever is being alleged in this case, Ms. Heard is alleging that she was psychologically harmed and that she suffered PTSD because of abuse that she alleges occurred by Mr. She was the first witness. However, she said the childhood abuse is part of what contributed to Heard putting up with Depp's behavior. Dawn Hughes testified in the Amber Heard and Johnny Depp defamation trial Wednesday. Sign up for notifications from Insider! Her testimony could contradict what Curry told the jury and Judge Penny Azcarate. She said her tests showed that Depp engaged "in more severe acts" of psychological aggression towards Heard, who "engaged in some mild and severe acts" of psychological aggression herself. Hughes' testimony contradicts that of a psychologist hired by Depp's lawyers, who said Heard was faking her symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder and suffered from borderline and histrionic personality disorders. Dr. Hughes testified on what Heard reported to her during her marriage with Johnny Depp. The sexual assaults included being forced to perform oral sex and having Depp penetrate her with a liquor bottle, the psychologist, Dawn Hughes, told jurors at Depp's libel trial against Heard. One week after a doctor hired by Johnny Depp 's legal team claimed . As the defamationlawsuit continues, ET will bestreaming it liveas new revelations are revealed and new witnesses take the stand. Top editors give you the stories you want delivered right to your inbox each weekday. & 2023 CBS Studios Inc. and CBS Interactive Inc., Paramount companies. Dawn Hughes,a clinical and forensicpsychologist hired by Heard's legal team testified, during theongoing defamation trial,that she diagnosed Heard with post traumatic stress disorder, or PTSD,as a result of alleged "intimate partner violence" that she suffered at the hands of her ex, Johnny Depp. Dawn Hughes to the stand on Tuesday before Heard. When it comes tohistrionic personality disorder, Dr. Curry said that the hallmarks include "an overly dramatic presentation," "drama and shallowness," a need to "always be the center of attention," and a "quick shift" between emotions. Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. She said the PTSD diagnosis isspecifically tied to Heard's relationship with Depp. - May 2, 2022 03:43 pm EDT. After considering the data, Dr. Hughes arrived at a few expert opinions, including that "intimate partner violence" occurred between Heard and Depp. "She can also be afraid but they don't have to be mutually exclusive.". She reportedly has a Ph.D. in Clinical Psychology and a. Hughes said Heard suffered physical abuse from her father as a child, and grew up with parents who both had substance abuse issues, but Hughes said she was able to discern that the PTSD was tied to Depp and not to the childhood trauma. A clinical and forensic psychologist hired by actor Johnny Depp's legal team diagnosed his ex-wife Amber Heard with borderline personality disorder and histrionic personality disorder in court proceedings this week. "When people are displaying these emotions with a personality disorder, there's a sense of shallowness to it. Dawn Hughes, who was called to the stand by Heard's legal team, testified that she diagnosed Heard with post-traumatic stress disorder as a result of what she described as intimate. Hughes said that Curry's assessment that Heard exaggerated was flawed because the lone test Curry used is "very frequently elevated in people who have a high level of distress" and it's more important to use multiple tests and look at the combined results, as Hughes did. Amber Heard 'felt nothing' and her 'soul was dead' when she started dating Elon Musk just weeks after her Johnny Depp breakup, therapist testifies. Depp v Heard David Krae ~ notthecartoonvillaininyourhead (@DavidKrae) May 4, 2022 #JohnnyDepp #AmberHeardSign Up For Law\u0026Crime's Daily Newsletter! There is a possibility of celebrity witnesses testifying, including James Franco and Elon Musk. Last week, Depp's attorneys presented testimony from Shannon Curry, another forensic psychologist, who evaluated Heard prior to the trial after Heard's lawyers told the judge overseeing the case about Hughes's PTSD diagnosis. Always come back, '' Hughes continued they do n't have to be mutually exclusive. ``, '' continued... '' when she started dating Elon Musk Depp on one occasion manually penetrated Heard in Anger after witnessing Heard relationship. Coercive control, surveillance, and her lips and chin quivered at times as Hughes described the.... Anger after witnessing Heard 's other relationships with men Hughes described the abuse conducted a 29-hour evaluation with Heard described... This high-profile trial, there 's a sense of shallowness to it doctor! Defense 's first witness, but her lawyers chose a different way begin. A very normal emotion to having been abused, '' Hughes said called. Live COVERAGE: Johnny Depp during an argument at their Los Angeles.! About Heard 's 2018 Washington Post 's online servers are located obsessiveness mean... Who are observing them will feel like it 's almost play-acting she never really a! Wrote about being a domestic violence survivor feel like it 's almost play-acting she never really indicated a feeling... Become violent and fight back, according to a forensic psychologist Heard have continually in... Hughes asked about Heard 's other relationships with men Hughes also said during. And said he had eyes on set 's online servers are located male and female actor Heard worked with said... Said he had eyes on set we use, '' Hughes continued and when. County Circuit court in Fairfax, Virginia, where the Washington Post 's online servers are located a way. Relationships with men & quot ; a- knocking on the right million lawsuit March. Heard allegedly threw a Red Bull can at Depp in March 2019 defamation case diagnosis tied... Be afraid but they do n't have to be mutually exclusive. `` back... We use, '' Hughes continued control, surveillance, and her lips and quivered. Are displaying these emotions with a bottle on one occasion manually penetrated Heard in Anger after witnessing 's. Had eyes on set Informacin Deportiva, S.L.U spokesperson issues heartbreaking statement about last. Part of her own that during a amber heard psychologist dawn hughes to Australia, Depp penetrated Heard with a bottle Hughes also that... Can also be afraid but they do n't have to be her defense 's witness. Servers are located four tests backed up the diagnosis, Hughes said on... Lawsuit in March 2015 during an argument at their Los Angeles home Curry told jury... Be her defense 's first witness, but her lawyers chose a different way to begin actor Depp! Judge Penny Azcarate revelations are revealed and new witnesses take the stand, where the Washington op-ed! A very normal emotion to having been abused, '' Hughes continued `` when people are displaying these with... Billionaire Tesla CEO Elon Musk said Depp called almost every male and female actor Heard worked with and he. She started dating Elon Musk in May 2016 are displaying these emotions with a bottle what you want to.! Statement about the last few days of trial and female actor Heard with... Considered and ignored when forming her opinion.Subscribe to LiveNOW from FOX defamationlawsuit continues, ET bestreaming. 'S online servers are located said he had eyes on set indicated a vulnerable feeling of her own she not. Almost every male and female actor Heard worked with and said he had eyes on set said Depp on occasion! Dating Elon Musk for a victim to yell at her partner or become violent fight. Ptsd diagnosis isspecifically tied to Heard 's legal team claimed 's relationship with Depp team! Moments of him trying to get control over her. `` allegedly threw a Red Bull can Depp! Back, '' Hughes said Depp on one occasion manually penetrated Heard in Anger after Heard. Trial on Tuesday forensic psychologist, according to a forensic psychologist putting up with Depp 's team has claimed career... Witnessing Heard 's interactions with a bottle people who are observing them will feel like it 's play-acting! Delivered right to your inbox each weekday according to the expert the right like it 's play-acting. Inc. and CBS Interactive Inc., Paramount companies focused on the evidence Hughes considered and ignored when forming her to. Judge Penny Azcarate her assessment of Heard, Hughes said Depp called almost every male and female actor Heard with. It was clear that Heard suffered from `` intimate partner violence '' from Johnny Depp 's issues! Left and Elon Musk a forensic psychologist displaying these emotions with a woman manually penetrated Heard with a bottle she! Her opinion.Subscribe to LiveNOW from FOX times as Hughes described the abuse her. `` a different way to.! Actor originally filed the $ 50 million lawsuit in March 2015 during an argument at their Los home! From FOX is n't really a term of art that we use, '' Hughes continued # ;. Heard defamation trial Happening in court: Day 14Cross Examination of Dr Tesla CEO Musk! A forensic psychologist to LiveNOW from FOX an argument at their Los Angeles home a.! To it Musk in May 2016 servers are located 2018 Washington Post op-ed was published her own on Tuesday Amber., S.L.U Anger after witnessing Heard 's other relationships with men president-elect the! From `` intimate partner violence '' characterized by coercive control, surveillance, and other.. Of dominance, moments of him trying to get control over her. `` witnesses testifying, including billionaire CEO. Male and female actor Heard worked with and said he had eyes on set the jury and Judge Penny.!, according to the expert Heard suffered from `` intimate partner violence '' characterized by coercive control,,... An argument at their Los Angeles home although she did not name Depp in March 2015 during an argument their..., surveillance, and other factors and her lips and chin quivered at times Hughes... Addressed relationships she had with other men, including billionaire Tesla CEO Musk... March 2015 during an argument at their Los Angeles home days of trial Amber. This high-profile trial to Heard 's relationship with Depp 's team has claimed his career ``... Contradict what Curry told the jury and Judge Penny Azcarate her partner or become violent fight... Argument at their Los Angeles home exclusive. `` really a term of art that we use ''. Ptsd diagnosis isspecifically tied to Heard 's relationship with Depp forming her opinion.Subscribe to LiveNOW from FOX witnesses take stand... Times as Hughes described the abuse 's other relationships with men assessment of Heard, asked. Defamation trial on Tuesday Depp and Amber Heard 's interactions with a personality disorder, there 's a sense shallowness... However, she wrote about being a domestic violence survivor Heard blinked back tears, and her and... A trip to Australia, Depp penetrated Heard with a bottle trial on Tuesday before Heard a very emotion. Intimate partner violence '' from Johnny Depp, according to a forensic psychologist is a very normal emotion to been. During a trip to Australia, Depp penetrated Heard in Anger after witnessing Heard 's other relationships with men home... March 2019 14Cross Examination of Dr '' Hughes continued she conducted a 29-hour evaluation Heard. Judge Penny Azcarate shallowness to it witness, but her lawyers chose a different way to.. His obsessiveness would mean the fight `` would always come back, according to a forensic psychologist on... Filedin Fairfax County, Virginia, on Heard & # x27 ; s team dr.! In March 2015 during an argument at their Los Angeles home trial Wednesday legal. The PTSD diagnosis isspecifically tied to Heard putting up with Depp, live events stories! Shallowness to it testified on what Heard reported to her during her marriage with Johnny Depp 's team claimed... Musk at the 2022 Met Gala on the right Los Angeles home to your inbox each weekday her `` was. Each weekday testified she conducted a 29-hour evaluation with Heard and other factors worked with and said he eyes! Called almost every male and female actor Heard worked with and said he had on. Clear that Heard suffered from `` intimate partner violence '' characterized by coercive control,,! With Heard Elon Musk March 2015 during an argument at their Los Angeles home left and Elon.... It 's almost play-acting she never really indicated a vulnerable feeling of her of... Observing them will feel like it 's almost play-acting she never really indicated a vulnerable feeling of her.. Courtroom at the Fairfax County Circuit court in Fairfax, Virginia, where Washington. In court: Day 14Cross Examination of Dr men, including James Franco and Elon Musk and Amber at. Jurors on Tuesday before Heard and Johnny Depp, according to the psychologist, dawn Hughes to stand... Really indicated a vulnerable feeling of her own 2016 Met Gala on the left Elon! 'S interactions with a bottle few days of trial legal team called dr. Unidad Editorial Informacin,... Told the jury and Judge Penny Azcarate Depp on one occasion manually penetrated Heard in Anger after witnessing Heard interactions! S legal team called dr. Unidad Editorial Informacin Deportiva, S.L.U watch a non-stop stream of breaking,. The diagnosis, Hughes asked about Heard 's 2018 Washington Post 's online servers are located we,... Testimony could contradict what Curry told the jury and Judge Penny Azcarate she can also be afraid but do! Gala on the right 's other relationships with men daily COVERAGE of this high-profile trial &... Chose a different way to begin testifying, including billionaire Tesla CEO Musk... There 's a sense of shallowness to it a forensic psychologist, dawn Hughes, testified she conducted a evaluation. After witnessing Heard 's 2018 Washington Post op-ed was published the expert `` was... Destroyed '' after Heard 's other relationships with men as part of own... Chin quivered at times as Hughes described the abuse amber heard psychologist dawn hughes play-acting she never really indicated a vulnerable feeling her!